
Long Island Holiday Bazaars and Craft Fairs 2026, Weekend by Weekend
Church bazaars, school craft fairs and holiday markets across Long Island for November and December 2026, Thanksgiving weekend included, grouped by weekend, with a way to hit several in one Saturday.
Every fall the yard sales thin out and the church halls fill up. Parish centers, Lutheran fellowship rooms, high school gyms and old lodge halls across Long Island turn into holiday markets for a Saturday or two, and they are some of the best shopping of the year if you like handmade gifts, bake tables and a back room full of donated treasures priced to go.
The catch is that they are scattered. One is in a flyer taped to a deli door, one is on a church website, one is in a community calendar. So here is the 2026 schedule in one place, grouped by weekend, with each fair linked to its page on Hopper where you can see the hours, the map pin and get directions.
Most church and school fairs on this list are free to walk into. Where a listing says free admission, or names a price at the door, it is noted below.
Dates and hours below were checked against each event's own listing when this post was last updated. Plans change, so tap through to the listing before you drive.
Friday, November 20 to Sunday, November 22
The biggest weekend of the season. Saturday the 21st alone has thirteen holiday events on Long Island, from Franklin Square out to the North Fork.
Friday
- Thrift Shop Gift and Bag Sale at Simpson United Methodist, Amityville. Friday, 10 AM to 1 PM.
Saturday
- Community Presbyterian Holiday Fair, Deer Park. 9:30 AM to 3 PM, free admission. Raffles, a cookie corner, crafts and photos with Santa, with lunch available.
- Ascension Lutheran Holiday Craft Fair, Deer Park. 10 AM to 4 PM. Two fairs in the same town on the same day.
- Grace United Methodist Christmas Craft Fair, Lindenhurst. 9 AM to 3 PM.
- New Interdisciplinary School Craft Fair, Yaphank. 10 AM to 3 PM.
- Walt Whitman High School Crafts Fair, Huntington Station. 10 AM to 5 PM.
- Waldorf School of Garden City Holiday Craft Market, Garden City. 10 AM to 4 PM.
- Wesley United Methodist Holiday Fair, Franklin Square. 10 AM to 3 PM.
- Vendor and Craft Market at St. John's Lutheran, Merrick. 10 AM to 3 PM.
- Holiday Craft and Vendor Fair at Hicksville High School, Hicksville. 9 AM to 3 PM. Its first year, run by the East Street PTA. Use the back parking lot and the back entrance.
- Santaport Fair and Christmas Market at Centerport United Methodist, Centerport. 10 AM to 3 PM. A European style market with wreaths, holiday decor, handcrafted gifts and a bake table.
- Southold Town Holiday Fair, Peconic. 9 AM to 4 PM, free admission, at the Southold Town Recreation Center. More than 40 vendors, a cafe with homemade chili and soup, and Santa from 1 to 3.
Saturday and Sunday
- East Islip High School Craft Fair, Islip Terrace. Both days, 10 AM to 4 PM, free admission.
- Holiday Gift and Vendor Fair at Otto's Sea Grill, Freeport. Both days, noon to 5 PM, on the Nautical Mile. Handmade crafts and jewelry with new artists each week, plus a clearance of coastal gift shop pieces.
Sunday
- Mid-Island Collectibles Toy Show at the Broadway Mall, Hicksville. 11 AM to 5 PM, 5 dollars at the door, kids under 12 free. Not a craft fair, but a good stop for anyone with a collector on their list.
Also that Saturday: an indoor multi-family garage sale at Kings Park High School, noon to 6 PM, a fundraiser for the Commack-Kings Park Rotary. Tools, vinyl, golf clubs, kitchen gear, books and collectibles, all under one roof.
Thanksgiving weekend, November 27 to 29
Most church fairs take Thanksgiving weekend off, but there is still a full day of shopping if you want out of the house after the leftovers.
- Holiday Market at Hofstra USA, Uniondale. Friday, Saturday and Sunday, 10 AM to 5 PM, free admission, at 215 Liberty Blvd. A yearly Thanksgiving weekend market with local artisans, makers, small businesses and specialty vendors selling handcrafted goods and gifts.
- Rummage Sale at Montauk Community Church, Montauk. Saturday, 9 AM to noon, rain or shine. Short hours, so go early.
- Fishing and Boating Flea Market, Lindenhurst. Sunday, 9 AM to 2 PM, 5 dollars admission. New and used fishing and boating gear from vendors, which makes it an easy gift run for the angler in the family.
Saturday, December 5 and Sunday, December 6
- Holiday Gift Fair at Gabino Hall, Medford. Sunday, noon to 5 PM, free admission, on Route 112. Vendors, live music, raffles, food for purchase and a visit from Santa.
Saturday, December 12 and Sunday, December 13
- Rummage Sale at Montauk Community Church, Montauk. Saturday, 9 AM to noon, rain or shine.
Later in December
More holiday fairs get added each week as churches, schools and towns announce their dates. The newest ones show up on Events this weekend first, and you can narrow it down with the this weekend pages for Nassau County and Suffolk County.
How to hit four fairs in one Saturday
November 21 is the day this gets fun, and also the day it gets confusing. Thirteen fairs, thirteen sets of hours, and they open at different times: Lindenhurst, Hicksville and Peconic at 9, Deer Park's first fair at 9:30, most of the rest at 10, and Otto's in Freeport not until noon. If you start at the wrong one you spend the morning doubling back.
That is the problem Hopper was built for. Open the map, switch to Events, set the date to Saturday, and tap the fairs you want to hit. Hopper puts them in order by when the doors open, using real drive times, so you are not sitting in a parking lot waiting for a gym to open while another fair across town already has a line.
Holiday fairs take longer than a driveway sale. You walk the tables, you stop at the bake sale, you talk to the person who made the ornaments. Hopper plans each event stop at about 45 minutes instead of a quick driveway stop, so a four-fair Saturday comes out realistic instead of wishful.
A few things that make the day go smoother:
- Bring small bills. Some church fairs and bake tables are cash only, and nobody wants to break a fifty for a two dollar cookie.
- Bring a bag or two. Handmade gifts and attic finds pile up quickly.
- Check the closing time before you plan the last stop. Most of these wrap up by 3 or 4. Walt Whitman in Huntington Station, the Kings Park garage sale and Otto's in Freeport run until 5 or later on the 21st, which makes them good finishers.
- Look in the back room. The tables up front are the crafters. The rummage room, the attic sale or the thrift corner is where the donated vintage decor tends to end up.
If you want the longer version of route planning, the yard sale route planner page walks through how it works. The same idea of ordering stops by opening time works for any Saturday, and our guide on how to plan an efficient yard sale route covers it step by step.
The annual ones worth bookmarking
Some of these come back every year at the same hall on about the same weekend. Hopper now keeps one permanent page for each of those, so next year's dates land on the same page you bookmarked this year:
- Valley Stream Lions Charity Flea Market
- Hoarders Flea Market at The Maples in Manorville
- Temple Isaiah of Great Neck Tag Sale
- Temple Beth El of Huntington Rummage Sale
Browse by town
If you would rather stay close to home, every town on this list has its own page with the yard sales, garage sales and events posted there:
St. James, Medford, Holbrook, Merrick, Hauppauge, Greenport, Bayport, Brentwood, Montauk, Valley Stream, Amityville, Deer Park, Lindenhurst, Yaphank, Huntington Station, Garden City, Franklin Square, Islip Terrace, Freeport, Hicksville, Centerport, Peconic, Kings Park and Hempstead and Uniondale.
Earlier this season
The weekend of November 14 and 15 opened the season: the Scandinavian Holiday Bazaar at Norway Hall in St. James, the St. Sylvester Holiday Fair in Medford, the St. John's Lutheran Holiday Craft Fair in Holbrook, the Hauppauge High School Craft Fair, the Holiday Gift Market at Peconic Landing in Greenport, Granny's Christmas Attic Sale at Bayport United Methodist, the Brentwood Presbyterian rummage sale and the Valley Stream Lions Charity Flea Market. Those are done for 2026.
Running a fair this season?
If your church, school, library or club is hosting a holiday fair, bazaar or rummage sale on Long Island, add it to Hopper. It is free, it puts your event on the map next to the others, and it gives shoppers a way to fit you into their Saturday.
Find it. Map it. Hop it.